LinkedIn
      Join now Sign in
      General David H. Petraeus, US Army (Ret.)

      General David H. Petraeus, US Army (Ret.)

      Partner, KKR & Chairman, KKR Global Institute

      1y
      • Report this post

      I have been a bit struck by the Washington Post series on Afghanistan and its conclusion that American leaders did not tell the truth about what was going on in Afghanistan. I have also been a bit surprised at assertions that the documents obtained were hugely revelatory, given that the Special Inspector General regularly published documents and lessons learned reports criticizing aspects of the campaign. I generally agree with the article below. Yes, there were many mistakes made. Yes, Afghan corruption, political infighting, and ineptitude were maddening. And, certainly, it is hard to help establish the rule of law in a country whose major export crop is illegal. But most of us tried to be as accurate and as measured as possible. In an interview with Diane Sawyer in my final months as the Commander in Afghanistan, I refused to even use the word "winning," stating merely that we had achieved hard-fought progress, but that it was fragile and reversible (words I used, as well, in my March 15, 2011 testimony to the SASC). (And we had achieved progress, reversing the momentum on the battlefield that the Taliban had enjoyed until the summer of 2010.) https://lnkd.in/epxFghS

      There Was No “Secret War on the Truth” in Afghanistan

      There Was No “Secret War on the Truth” in Afghanistan

      https://warontherocks.com

      1,749 283 Comments
      Like Comment Share
      Thomas Anthony
      Thomas Anthony
      What was the objective? (Nor clear, not achieved)
      Sign in to like this comment
      Sign in to reply to this comment
      1 Like
      1y
      • Report this comment
      Tom Raquer
      Tom Raquer
      How did you ever think you could transform a distant Muslim land whose values and beliefs are the opposite of our Western beliefs into anything near your vision of what you thought Afghanistan should or could be. You have not the legitimacy or the capability to do so. The source of our Afghanistan Lies is our elite’s Woodenheadness, or self-deception, which is to analyze a situation according to preconceived notions despite evidence to the contrary. Our leaders decided,despite the contrary evidence, that for our safety Afghanistan needed to be a stable democratic nation and that THEY had the ability to make this transformation come about. They analyzed and set the political objectives for Afghanistan according to what they wanted it to be and not what it is or could be. Truly fantastical thinking.
      Sign in to like this comment
      Sign in to reply to this comment
      4 Likes
      1y
      • Report this comment

      To view or add a comment, sign in To view or add a comment, sign in

      General David H. Petraeus, US Army (Ret.)

      40,016 followers

      • 349 Posts
      • 6 Articles
      View Profile Follow

      More from this author

      • Into the second week: Thoughts on Personal Activities During the Campaign Against COVID-19 (If All Else Fails, Watch the Grass Grow!)

        General David H. Petraeus, US Army (Ret.) · 1y

      • Revisiting a piece from the Washington Post published 3-1/2 years ago, with concepts relevant in the current debate over U.S. policy on Syria...

        General David H. Petraeus, US Army (Ret.) · 2y

      • From "The Cipher Brief:" Four Big Takeaways from the Munich Security Conference

        General David H. Petraeus, US Army (Ret.) · 2y

      • LinkedIn © 2021
      • About
      • Accessibility
      • User Agreement
      • Privacy Policy
      • Cookie Policy
      • Copyright Policy
      • Brand Policy
      • Guest Controls
      • Community Guidelines